Verified Document

Social Revolutions Over The 20th Term Paper

Society gets its due share of attention; but as is fitting and absolutely essential in any discussion of revolution, it is the peculiar nature of and crisis of the state that occupies the centre of the stage." Similarly, Michael Kimmel of the University of California -- Santa Cruz,12 states that "Theda Skocpol is perhaps the most ambitious and exciting of a new generation of historical-comparative sociologists who have focused their attention squarely on the big issues of social change that once preoccupied the classic sociologists."

The difficulty that some reviewers had about this book is because of some of the misinformation. For example, George Yaney 12 of the University of Maryland states it is based almost entirely on secondary sources in French and English. Also, "One can find flaws in Skocpol's book. First, it fails to offer a sold theoretical structure to replace the ones she mauls. Having torn up Marx's analysis pretty severely, Skocpol still, from time to time, offers up Marxist canons and metaphors as if their validity could still be taken for granted." She also hands out vague sociological generalizations in parts of the book as if they were concrete historical descriptions. Yet, given that, he adds, "it would be pedantic to dwell on flaws and weaknesses. Skocpol's purpose is to set forth new perspectives, not to write up a new theory or discover new data, and I think she has done her job very well." He notes, as others have, it is not easy to combine academic disciplines and even harder to write on comparative history. She has managed to do both together and should be congratulated for doing so. She is, on the whole, a careful scholar and must be a courageous person.

Yaney ends his book review discussing Skocpol's contribution on why an agrarian revolution developed in Russia but not in Prussia-Germany. In Prussia, the peasants lost almost all their land but in Russia the government assured them a relatively large amount. As a result, agriculture in Prussia-Germany advanced and became productive in the former, but not in Russia. He then states: "One can support or attack this interpretation in a number of ways, but it is exciting...

She is not only daring to write about such an extensive topic, but also to write about it knowing that she is opening herself up to the Yaneys of the world and their commentaries -- good and bad. That is indeed very courageous and the way that new ideas come into the world.
Endnotes

Theda Skocpol, States and Social Revolutions (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1979), xi

Ibid.,5

Krishan Kumar "States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia and China by Theda Skocpol" the British Journal of Sociology. 31, no. 2 (1980), 310-311. www.jstor.org.libdb.fairfield.edu/search/BasicResults?Search=Search&Query=aa:%22Krishan%20Kumar%22&hp=25&si=1"

Michael Kimmel "States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia, and China. By Theda Skocpol." http://www.jstor.org.libdb.fairfield.edu/browse/00029602" the American Journal of Sociology. 86 No.5 (1981) 1145-1154

George Yaney "States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia, and China." Slavic Review. 39 no. 3, (1980) 496-499

References

Kimmel, Michael. "States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia, and China. By Theda Skocpol." http://www.jstor.org.libdb.fairfield.edu/browse/00029602" the American Journal of Sociology. 86 No.5 (1981): 1145-1154

Kumar, Krishan. States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France,

Russia and China by Theda Skocpol" the British Journal of Sociology. 31, no. 2

1980): 310-311.

Skocpol, Theda. States and Social Revolutions New York: Cambridge University Press, 1979

Yaney, George. "States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia, and China." Slavic Review. 39 no. 3, (1980): 496-499

Sources used in this document:
References

Kimmel, Michael. "States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia, and China. By Theda Skocpol." http://www.jstor.org.libdb.fairfield.edu/browse/00029602" the American Journal of Sociology. 86 No.5 (1981): 1145-1154

Kumar, Krishan. States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France,

Russia and China by Theda Skocpol" the British Journal of Sociology. 31, no. 2

1980): 310-311.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

20th Century and Ballet
Words: 2047 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Ballet George Balanchine and Serge Diaghilev were similar and yet different in various ways. For instance, both were prominent figures in the 20th century: they worked together in the Ballets Russes for five years in the latter half of the 1920s; Balanchine was the choreographer and ballet master, Diaghilev the promoter. Diaghilev had staged works, too, and is regarded as a pioneer in the field -- uniting new music and modernist

Revolutions of the Early 20th
Words: 1186 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

" The revolution was also responsible for establishing "conditions for an era of economic development. Capitalist development had begun in Mexico prior to the revolution, but it had been constrained by the power of the large landholders and lacked the sponsorship of an active, development-oriented state (MacEwan)." During the 1920s and 1930s, the modern Mexican state "came to embody the dual heritage of the Mexican revolution, representing and containing the interests

Social Impact of Cold War & Terrorism
Words: 1772 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Social Impact of Cold War & Terrorism The Cold War is often associated with the idea of making great and physical divides between the good and the bad of the world. It was a symbolic representation that extended for about 30 years on the expectation that the greatest powers of the world could, under the right circumstances, impose a sort of benign order on the planet by isolating the evil empires

Social Constructionism and Its Application to the Historiography...
Words: 4748 Length: 13 Document Type: Research Paper

Social Constructionism and Historiography of Science In the historiography of science, the debate between intenalists and externalists has been one of the major fault lines over the past century. While many historians are not specialists in physics, chemistry and biology, by training and experience they also consider the political, economic and cultural influences on any institution and organization in a given period, and science his not been exempt from historicism. Internlaists

Social Work As a Social Movement
Words: 660 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Social Work as a Social Movement During the early part of the 20th century, social work was a way of helping individuals, but did little to question the status quo of larger groups of people. However, beginning in the 1950s, broad-based social movements began to challenge relationships that had previously been seen as private. While the underpinnings of these movements began in the 1950s, they became prominent in the 1960s. These

20th Century, Political Philosophers in
Words: 515 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

" 2 One of the most important technological developments that occurred during the Industrial Revolution was the assembly line. Used in large factories so that more goods could be manufactured in a shorter period of time, assembly lines totally transformed the way people lived and worked. First, the assembly line created a plethora of new jobs, encouraging previously self-sufficient farmers to move to urban centers. Families were occasionally disrupted and old social

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now